Introduction:
In the realm of country music, introspection and poignant storytelling are hallmarks of the genre. Toby Keith’s “What Made The Baby Cry?” exemplifies these qualities, offering a contemplative ballad that transcends the typical themes of love and loss. Released in 1991 on Keith’s debut album “Toby Keith”, the song delves into profound questions about humanity and the nature of suffering.
Toby Keith, a name synonymous with American patriotism and redneck anthems, surprised audiences with this introspective track. While known for his signature gruff vocals and bravado on songs like “Should’ve Been a Cowboy,” “What Made The Baby Cry?” showcases a different side of Keith. Here, his voice softens, conveying a sense of wonder and vulnerability as he ponders the mysteries of the world.
The mastermind behind the music is songwriter William J. Golay. Golay, a prolific songwriter who has penned hits for artists like Kenny Rogers and Randy Travis, crafted a poetic lyric for “What Made The Baby Cry?”. The song opens with a vivid winter scene, setting the stage for a profound meditation on the human condition.
“What Made The Baby Cry?” didn’t achieve mainstream chart success, but it resonated deeply with fans. The song became a favorite among Keith’s loyal following, particularly those who appreciated his ability to delve into deeper themes. “What Made The Baby Cry?” has become a staple at Keith’s concerts, often performed as a slow ballad that allows for a more intimate connection with the audience.
The song’s enduring appeal lies in its ability to spark contemplation. “What Made The Baby Cry?” doesn’t offer easy answers, instead prompting listeners to consider the suffering that exists in the world, even in the eyes of a newborn child. Is it a premonition of the pain to come? Does an infant inherently understand the world’s troubles? These are the questions that linger after the final notes fade, making “What Made The Baby Cry?” a thought-provoking and emotionally resonant ballad in Toby Keith’s discography.
Video:
Lyrics:
On a cold night, late DecemberAs the snow fell to earthThat’s the one night, we rememberWhen a woman gave birthAnd for miles and miles aroundThe baby’s cry was the only soundDid He know the world was filled with painCould He feel all the hunger and the shameOr did He know about the way He would dieAnd the reason whyIs that what made the baby cry?Is that what made the baby cry?As his Mother turned to hold HimHer face filled with joyHe grew quiet when She told HimHe was more than just her baby boyAnd for miles and miles aroundHer lullaby was the only soundDid She know the world was filled with painCould She feel all the hunger and the shameOr did She know about the way He would dieAnd the reason whyIs that what made Her baby cry?Is that what made Her baby cry?And as He fell asleepShe wiped away His tearsBut the question still remainsHave we changed in two thousand yearsDon’t you know the world is still in painCan’t you feel all the hunger and the shameDid we forget about the way that He diedAnd the reason whyWould we still make the baby cry?Would we still make the baby cry?