Introduction:
Now, Toby Keith is a name synonymous with American grit and a no-nonsense attitude. This Oklahoma native built his career on songs that celebrated rural life, patriotism, and the working man’s spirit. If I Was Jesus doesn’t stray too far from those themes, but it throws in a hefty dose of religious contemplation, which is what truly set it apart.
The song was co-written by Keith alongside Kelley McGuire, a seasoned songwriter known for her work with artists like Tim McGraw and Faith Hill. If I Was Jesus was produced by Keith along with Jimmy Johnson, a frequent collaborator who helped shape the signature sound of Toby Keith throughout his career.
If I Was Jesus wasn’t a huge commercial success on the charts. It didn’t crack the Top 40 on the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart, which might surprise some considering Keith’s usual commercial clout. However, the song’s impact went far beyond chart numbers. If I Was Jesus sparked a national conversation about faith, politics, and the role of religion in everyday life.
The song’s lyrics take the form of a first-person monologue, with Keith pondering what he would do differently if he were placed in Jesus’s shoes. He ponders social issues, economic struggles, and the ever-present shadow of war. If I Was Jesus, it becomes clear, isn’t a straightforward gospel tune. It’s a song that grapples with complex questions and offers a distinctly American perspective on faith.
What truly ignited the debate was Keith’s characteristically blunt delivery. If I Was Jesus doesn’t shy away from hot-button issues, and some listeners found the song’s directness to be disrespectful or even blasphemous. However, others praised the song’s honesty and its willingness to engage with difficult topics.
Love it or hate it, If I Was Jesus is a song that left its mark. It’s a testament to Toby Keith’s ability to stir the pot and get people talking. Whether you find yourself agreeing with the song’s message or not, there’s no denying that If I Was Jesus is a thought-provoking piece of country music that continues to spark conversation even today.
Video:
Lyrics:
“If I Was Jesus”
A robe and some sandals, is exactly what I’d wear
I’d be the guy at the party, turnin’ water to wine
Yeah me and my disciples, we’d have a real good time.Ooh and I’d lay my life down for you (woooooh)
And I show you who’s the boss (woooooh)
I’d forgive you and adore you
While I was hangin’ on your cross
If I Was Jesus.
I’d have some friends that were poor
I’d run around with the wrong crowd, man I’d never be bored
Then I’d heal me a blind man, get myself crucified
By politicians and preachers, who got somethin’ to hide.
Ooh and I’d lay my life down for you (woooooh)
And I show you who’s the boss (woooooh)
I’d forgive you and adore you
While I was hangin’ on your cross
If I Was Jesus.
If I Was Jesus, I’d come back from the dead
And I’d walk on some water, just to mess with your head
I know your dark little secrets, I’d look you right in the face
And I’d tell you I love you, with Amazing Grace.
Ooh and I’d lay my life down for you (woooooh)
And I show you who’s the boss (woooooh)
I’d forgive you and adore you
While I was hangin’ on your cross
If I Was Jesus.
If I Was Jesus.